I have seen both of the more expensive lights used and frankly, I prefer the Shades of Light but of course it's a matter of personal taste. The Home Depot light could be really effective (every room needs a little black) & could probably be refinished in a different colour with a little elbow grease if need be.
Note all prices are FOB US and do not include any shipping or import costs.
I enjoyed the article in Saturday's Globe and Mail about a reno of an Edwardian era heritage home near Fraser & Kingsway featuring local architect Michel Laflamme. It's a wonderful example of how an existing space can be reworked and updated maximizing the use of space with builtins & adding light with new finishes like back painted glass & glass doors. Click HERE for full article & more photos.